Lasry Academy Orthodox Conversion

Faith in God · 7 min read · November 16, 2026

How Do We Know the Torah Is True?

Why Jewish tradition points to a public revelation at Sinai and a chain of transmission, what Maimonides says, and what kind of argument this is.

By Rabbi Yitzchak Lasry

Golden light shining on a desert mountain at sunrise

Every religion says it is true. So how would anyone, honestly, check?

Rabbi Lasry places this question at the beginning of his course on Jewish faith. In his introduction to the Thirteen Principles of Faith he asks it openly: how do we know that Judaism is right, when millions and billions of people follow other paths? He does not treat the question as a threat. He treats it as the place to start. This article follows the answer he gives and sets it beside the sources it rests on. It presents the position of the Jewish tradition, and it says plainly where that position is a claim of faith and tradition and not a proof that settles the matter for everyone.

Quotations from the Torah below use the 1917 Jewish Publication Society translation, which is in the public domain. Translations of other sources are our own paraphrase.

The claim at the center

Judaism does not rest its case on a single founder's private experience. The Torah makes a different kind of claim: that God spoke at Mount Sinai to an entire people at once.

Before the event, God tells Moses: "Lo, I come unto thee in a thick cloud, that the people may hear when I speak with thee, and may also believe thee for ever" (Exodus 19:9). The people themselves are to be witnesses, so that their trust does not depend on Moses alone.

Later Moses invites the people to consider the claim: "Did ever a people hear the voice of God speaking out of the midst of the fire, as thou hast heard, and live?" (Deuteronomy 4:33). And again: "The LORD spoke with you face to face in the mount out of the midst of the fire" (Deuteronomy 5:4).

Notice what the text is doing. It does not ask the reader to accept a private vision. It appeals to the shared memory of a whole nation.

What Rabbi Lasry teaches

Rabbi Lasry makes this the core of his answer. Judaism, he teaches, rests on a public revelation: an event experienced by a whole people, as opposed to an experience reported by one person. The Jewish people recall it every time the Torah is read and every Passover when the Haggadah is recited.

He adds a second pillar: an unbroken chain of transmission. Each teacher received the tradition from a teacher. The Rabbi gives the example of rabbinic authority, which a rabbi receives from his own rabbi, going back through the generations. The Mishnah describes this chain in its first lines: Moses received the Torah at Sinai and handed it on to Joshua, Joshua to the elders, the elders to the prophets, and the prophets to the Men of the Great Assembly (Pirkei Avot 1:1).

He also teaches the traditional belief that the written Torah is a fixed text, in line with the Torah's own words: "Ye shall not add unto the word which I command you, neither shall ye diminish from it" (Deuteronomy 4:2).

Maimonides: why Sinai, and not wonders

A classical source asks the obvious follow-up: what exactly convinced the people? In his code of law, Maimonides answers that the people did not believe in Moses because of the wonders he performed. A belief that rests on wonders, he writes, always leaves a doubt, since a wonder might be done through sorcery. The wonders in the desert each met a need, such as drowning the Egyptians or providing food and water. They were not offered as proof of his prophecy.

What, then, was the basis? In his words: b'ma'amad Har Sinai she'eineinu ra'u v'lo zar, v'oznenu sham'u v'lo acher (במעמד הר סיני שעינינו ראו ולא זר ואזנינו שמעו ולא אחר), which means, in free translation, "at the standing at Mount Sinai: our eyes saw it and not a stranger's, our ears heard it and not another's." Maimonides writes that the people's knowledge came from what they themselves saw and heard, and that this is why a later prophet performing wonders to contradict Moses would not be heeded (Mishneh Torah, Foundations of the Torah 8:1-3).

In short: the Jewish answer to "how do we know?" is not "because of miracles" but "because of what, according to our tradition, a whole people experienced and remembered."

How large was the people? The numbers

The Torah itself gives a figure for the men. At the Exodus, the people journeyed "about six hundred thousand men on foot, beside children" (Exodus 12:37). The census in the wilderness counted 603,550 men from twenty years old and upward, and it did not count the tribe of Levi (Numbers 1:3, 1:45-47; see also Numbers 11:21). A "mixed multitude" went up with them as well (Exodus 12:38).

These verses count men only. They do not state the number of women, children and the elderly. If one adds women and children to the roughly 600,000 men over twenty (Exodus 12:37; Numbers 1:46 counts 603,550), the total reaches about three million. This is a traditional estimate, a conjecture computed from the verse-based figure. It is not a number stated in any verse, and it is not attributed to a named sage. This article does not claim otherwise.

What this does, and does not, prove

An honest article should say what kind of argument this is.

It is an argument from tradition and national memory. Its logic is that a claim of mass experience is different in kind from a claim of private experience: it would be very hard to introduce such a claim into a people's memory if it were not true, because everyone would know they had not been there. The Torah uses this reasoning when it challenges the people to "ask" (Deuteronomy 4:32).

This is the position of the Jewish tradition. It is not presented here as historical proof beyond dispute. A skeptic can answer that the argument assumes the historical event, and that it is only as strong as one's trust in the transmission. That is a fair point, and the tradition does not claim that faith disappears once the argument is made. The Rabbi teaches that belief is more than agreement in the head: to believe is to live by it. The argument is an invitation to take the claim seriously, to study, and to test it by living with it.

This article does not evaluate other religions, and it does not say that anyone who sees things differently is foolish. It lays out why Jewish tradition holds what it holds.

What it means for someone exploring conversion

A conversion asks you to accept the Torah as binding, so it is reasonable to ask what the basis is. Two suggestions follow from the sources. First, read the passages themselves, Exodus 19 and 20 and Deuteronomy 4 and 5, slowly, and notice how the Torah describes its own claim. Second, ask a teacher your questions, and expect the answers to take time.

This is not a substitute for the process of conversion. That is decided by a Beit Din, a rabbinic court, and no course or article can guarantee an outcome. To see how the process works, read How Does Orthodox Conversion Work? The revelation at Sinai also stands behind the idea of the covenant, which you can read about in Why Did God Choose the Jewish People?

Reflection questions

  • What is the difference between trusting a founder's report and trusting a nation's memory?
  • Maimonides says wonders are not the basis. Does that change what you expect from a religious proof?

Key takeaways

  • The Torah claims a public revelation before a whole people, not a private vision (Exodus 19:9; Deuteronomy 4:32-33; 5:4).
  • Rabbi Lasry teaches two supports: that public revelation, and an unbroken chain of transmission from teacher to student.
  • Maimonides says the people's belief rested on what they themselves saw and heard at Sinai, not on wonders (Foundations of the Torah 8:1-3).
  • The Torah counts about 600,000 men (Exodus 12:37). The figure of about three million for the whole people is a traditional estimate computed from the verse-based count of the men, not a number stated in a verse.

An invitation

If you are thinking about Orthodox conversion, Lasry Academy offers a structured course of study in Jewish belief, practice and the calendar. The course does not guarantee conversion, which is decided by a Beit Din. Your first 15-minute consultation with Rabbi Yitzchak Lasry is completely free.

Book your free 15-minute consultation

Learn more on the Orthodox Conversion Course page.

Ready to Begin Your Jewish Journey?

Discover our structured Orthodox Conversion Course with Rabbi Yitzchak Lasry. Learn about Jewish faith, Shabbat, Kashrut, Jewish holidays, prayer, and the practical steps toward Orthodox Jewish life.

Study online, receive guidance, and prepare for the conversion process with the support of a Jewish community and a sponsoring rabbi.

Your first 15-minute Zoom consultation is completely FREE.

Completing the course does not guarantee conversion. The decision belongs to the Beit Din.

← Back to the blog

Related Articles