Lasry Academy Orthodox Conversion

Orthodox Conversion · 7 min read · November 16, 2026

Why Doesn't Judaism Seek Converts?

Why a rabbi first asks about motives and explains the difficulties: a test of sincerity, not a barrier. Rambam, the Talmud, and the seven Noahide laws.

By Rabbi Yitzchak Lasry

An open wooden door in a stone arch leading to a path toward a walled city

If Judaism is true, shouldn't it want everyone to know? Many religions send out missionaries. Judaism does the opposite. A person who asks an Orthodox rabbi about converting is often met with questions, a warning that the path is hard, and a gentle suggestion to think again. To a newcomer this can feel like rejection. In fact it says something important about how Judaism understands itself, and about what it asks of those who join.

Rabbi Lasry addresses the question directly in his lessons. This article follows what he teaches and compares it with the Torah and the Talmud on the same subject.

Judaism does not seek converts

In his lesson on Judaism, Christianity and Islam, Rabbi Lasry states the starting point plainly: Judaism is not a universal religion that seeks converts. God's covenant with Israel at Mount Sinai created specific obligations for the Jewish people, and non-Jews have their own path.

This does not close the door. It reflects a different structure. A Jew is born into a set of obligations that include Shabbat, kosher food, daily prayer and many other commandments. A non-Jew is not asked to carry those, and the tradition does not treat that as a lack.

A path for everyone: the seven Noahide laws

Jewish tradition teaches that all of humanity, as the descendants of Noah, is commanded in seven universal laws. Maimonides lists them in his code of law: not worshipping idols, not blaspheming God, not murdering, not engaging in forbidden sexual relations, not stealing, establishing courts of justice, and not eating a limb torn from a living animal (Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings and Wars 9:1).

Maimonides also writes that Moses passed the Torah on as an inheritance to Israel and to anyone from the other nations who wishes to convert, and that a person who does not wish to accept it is not forced to (Laws of Kings and Wars 8:10). A non-Jew who accepts the seven laws and keeps them because God commanded them, as taught through Moses, is counted among the pious of the nations and has a share in the World to Come. If he keeps them only because reason leads him to them, he does not receive that status (Laws of Kings and Wars 8:11).

In other words, Judaism does not teach that a good life, or a share in the World to Come, depends on becoming Jewish. That is one of the clearest reasons Judaism has no need to chase converts.

Why Does Judaism Initially Discourage Potential Converts?

Unlike religions that actively seek converts, Orthodox Judaism follows a different approach. According to Jewish law, when someone approaches a rabbi or Beit Din seeking conversion, the initial response includes questioning the person's motivation and discouraging them by explaining the difficulties and responsibilities of Jewish life. This is not because Judaism rejects sincere converts. Rather, it is a traditional way of ensuring that the decision comes from genuine conviction, not temporary enthusiasm, social pressure, or personal convenience.

Maimonides explains in the Mishneh Torah (Laws of Forbidden Relations 14:1-2) that the prospective convert is asked why they wish to join the Jewish people and is informed of the hardships the Jewish people have endured. If the person understands these challenges and still sincerely wishes to join, he is accepted to continue and the process moves forward. The candidate is then introduced to the foundations of Jewish belief and to some of the lighter and more demanding commandments. The source in the Talmud is Yevamot 47a, and the Shulchan Aruch records the same procedure (Yoreh De'ah 268:2).

Importantly, Jewish law also teaches that a sincere candidate should not be excessively discouraged or overwhelmed. The Talmud says that the court does not overwhelm the person with warnings and does not press for every detail of the commandments (Yevamot 47b). Maimonides adds that the details are not taught all at once, because the person is drawn in gently, "with cords of a man" and "with bands of love" (Laws of Forbidden Relations 14:2; Hosea 11:4). The Talmud learns this from the story of Ruth. Naomi tried to turn Ruth back, and when she saw that Ruth was determined, "she left off speaking unto her" (Ruth 1:18; Yevamot 47b). A person who insists, after the difficulties have been explained, should not be delayed unnecessarily.

The purpose of the initial discouragement is to examine sincerity, not to create unnecessary obstacles. A candidate who asks questions at this stage is not being tested to be turned away. He is being treated seriously, as someone who is about to take on a covenant.

In Orthodox Judaism, conversion is not something we persuade people to do. It is a sacred commitment that a person must genuinely choose, understand, and be prepared to live.

Why people are drawn anyway

Rabbi Lasry makes a human observation: from the outside, converting makes little sense. Why add to your life something that makes it more complicated? Unless, he says, you feel a calling and a real connection to Hashem, it does not add up.

He also teaches, relying on the Talmud, that part of the reason the Jewish people were scattered across the world is that people from other nations could find their way to them. Rabbi Elazar taught that God exiled Israel among the nations so that converts would join them (Pesachim 87b).

The result is a tradition that welcomes the sincere without recruiting. The Rabbi's lessons add a further note for those who consider conversion: there are no shortcuts. Real change in daily life, community and practice is what counts, and not just information.

A light by example, not by pressure

If Judaism does not recruit, how does it relate to the wider world? The Rabbi's answer is that Israel has a universal mission, but not a missionary one. Citing Isaiah's description of Israel as "a light of nations" (Isaiah 49:6), he explains that the role works through example: ethical monotheism (belief in one God who demands moral conduct), justice and compassion. In his teaching, the light shines through example and inspiration, not through force.

What it means for someone exploring conversion

If you are considering conversion, do not be surprised if a rabbi asks about your reasons and describes the difficulties. That is not rejection, and it is not meant to push you away. It is how the tradition makes sure that the decision is yours and is made with the full picture. For the steps that follow, read How Does Orthodox Conversion Work? You can also ask these questions in a free consultation, below. Ask the rabbi why he asks what he asks, and expect to be treated with respect.

Notice also what this means for the people around you. Judaism does not ask your Christian, Muslim or secular relatives to become Jewish, and it does not teach that they are lost without it. You can honor that in your family while you learn. The decision on any conversion rests with a Beit Din, and no course or article can guarantee it.

Reflection questions

  • What does it say about a tradition that it asks a sincere seeker to pause before joining?
  • Why might freely offering a good life to all people, through universal commandments, be a form of respect?

Key takeaways

  • In the Rabbi's teaching, Judaism is not a universal religion seeking converts, because the covenant at Sinai created obligations specific to the Jewish people.
  • Non-Jews have a path of their own, the seven Noahide laws. According to Maimonides, one who keeps them because God commanded them is counted among the pious of the nations and has a share in the World to Come.
  • Conversion is for the sincere. The tradition first asks about motives and explains the difficulties, in order to examine sincerity and not to create obstacles. The decision belongs to a Beit Din.

An invitation

If you are thinking about Orthodox conversion, Lasry Academy offers a structured course of study in Jewish belief, practice and the calendar. The course does not guarantee conversion, which is decided by a Beit Din. Your first 15-minute consultation with Rabbi Yitzchak Lasry is completely free.

Book your free 15-minute consultation

Learn more on the Orthodox Conversion Course page.

Ready to Begin Your Jewish Journey?

Discover our structured Orthodox Conversion Course with Rabbi Yitzchak Lasry. Learn about Jewish faith, Shabbat, Kashrut, Jewish holidays, prayer, and the practical steps toward Orthodox Jewish life.

Study online, receive guidance, and prepare for the conversion process with the support of a Jewish community and a sponsoring rabbi.

Your first 15-minute Zoom consultation is completely FREE.

Completing the course does not guarantee conversion. The decision belongs to the Beit Din.

← Back to the blog

Related Articles